As you may or may not be aware, Pat Smith and I held a contest to discover who is the greatest animator of all time. We solicited people's top five lists starting in July and we've gotten some wonderful lists. I myself was amazed at the wonderful balance between studio animators and indie animators. Also there were a number of people left off the list that should have been there. Such as:
Ralph Bakshi
John Kricfaluci
Michel Ocelot
Konstantin Bronzit
Mike Judge
Tom Moore
But this event was such a big success that we're going to hold it again in a couple of years – and maybe do a best animation director. In any case, here are the results, read 'em and weep:
Hayao Miyazaki 9
Milt Kahl 8
Bill Plympton 7
Joanna Quinn 7
Nick Park 6
Aleksandr Petrov 6
Bill Tytla 6
Richard Williams 6
Tex Avery 5
Frédéric Back 5
Ward Kimball 5
Glen Keane 5
Norman McLaren 5
Ken Harris 4
Winsor McCay 4
Chuck Jones 4
Yuri Norstein 4
Rod Scribner 4
Frank Thomas 4
Jim Tyer 4
Koji Yamamura 4
Paul Driessen 3
Caroline Leaf 3
Jan Svankmayer 3
Alexander Alexeieff 2
James Baxter 2
Don Bluth 2
Bruno Bozzetto 2
Art Davis 2
Walt Disney 2
Michel Gagné 2
Emery Hawkins 2
Ollie Johnson 2
Yoshinori Kanada 2
John Lasseter 2
Fred Moore 2
Bob McKimson 2
Michaela Pavlatova 2
Masaaki Yuasa 2
Hideaki Anno 1
Mark Baker 1
Preston Blair 1
Bruce Bickford 1
Brad Castor 1
Osvaldo Cavandoli 1
Bobe Cannon 1
Sylvain Chomet 1
Cyriak 1
Tissa David 1
Michael Dudok de Wi t 1
Paul Fierlinger 1
Atsuko Fukushima 1
William Hanna & Joe Barbera 1
Eric Goldberg 1
François Giraud 1
Paul Grimault 1
Mitsuo Iso 1
Zlatko Grgic 1
Ray Harryhausen 1
Jim Henson 1
Don Hertzfeldt 1
Marcell Jankovics 1
Pavel Koutsky 1
Una Marzorati 1
Takashi Murakami 1
Koji Morimoto 1
Muto 1
Victor Navone 1
Go Nagai 1
Shinya Ohira 1
Katsuhiro Otomo 1
Shinji Otsuka 1
Yasuo Otsuka 1
Janet Pearlman 1
Sergio Pablos 1
Virgil Ross 1
Henry Selick 1
Tatsuyuki Tanaka 1
Phil Tippett 1
Isao Takahata 1
Jiri Trnka 1
Simon Tofield 1
Satoro Utsunomiya 1
Carlo Vinci 1
Don Williams 1
Karol Zeman 1
Great list.
ReplyDelete(But Bob McKimson only gets two?!)
Sad no one thought of Marc Davis...sniff.
ReplyDeleteFor what its worth I listed Bob McKimson for the actual animation he did under Bob Clampett. As a director, well, he did some funny shorts, but I never considered him the strongest of the three Warner's had at the time (other two being Freleng and Jones).
ReplyDeleteDid you actually count all my honorable mentions? Geez, I didn't expect that...
ReplyDelete